A military family adjusts a soldiers uniform while a young girl watches. The text reads SBP Pros & Cons and Career Military Families, highlighting the intricacies of Military retirement pay, alongside the US-VET WEALTH logo.

Military Survivor Benefit Plan (SBP): Understanding the Pros and Cons

Scott Tucker Updated on

Career military families face many complex financial decisions, especially when nearing retirement. The Survivor Benefit Plan (SBP) is a critical yet often overlooked choice. Despite its importance, SBP discussions frequently lack clarity, leaving military families unsure whether this option aligns with their long-term financial goals.

In this article, we’ll discuss the pros and cons of SBP, helping you make an informed decision about your family’s future.

What Is the Military Survivor Benefit Plan?

The Survivor Benefit Plan (SBP) was established to provide financial protection to surviving dependents of retired or deceased military members. It functions as an annuity that guarantees a percentage of the retiree’s pension continues to their designated beneficiary—usually a spouse—upon their death.

Key Features of SBP:

  • Automatic Enrollment: Married retirees are automatically enrolled unless the retiree and spouse opt-out.
  • Cost: Participants pay monthly premiums deducted from their pension, typically 6.5% of their retirement pay.
  • Irrevocable: Changes cannot be made without spousal consent once coverage begins.

How Does SBP Work?

SBP provides monthly payments to surviving beneficiaries in the event of a retiree’s death, ensuring a steady income stream. This program operates as a government-funded benefit during active duty. However, it becomes a cost-sharing program once the service member retires.

Important Considerations:

  • Inflation-Adjusted Payments: SBP payouts increase annually based on inflation.
  • Eligibility Requirements: The surviving spouse loses eligibility for SBP benefits if they remarry before age 55.
  • Default Enrollment: SBP is automatically applied unless explicitly declined during retirement.

Evaluating the Pros and Cons of SBP

Choosing SBP involves weighing its peace-of-mind benefits against its financial trade-offs. Here’s a closer look at the advantages and disadvantages.

The Pros of SBP

  • Guaranteed Income for Survivors: SBP ensures your beneficiary’s reliable, inflation-adjusted income stream, reducing financial uncertainty.
  • No Medical Underwriting: Unlike private life insurance, SBP doesn’t require medical exams, making it accessible for retirees with health conditions.
  • Simple Enrollment Process: Enrollment is streamlined, with automatic deductions from retirement pay and no need for additional contracts or negotiations.
  • Tax Advantages: Premiums are deducted from pre-tax income, which can reduce the retiree’s taxable income.

The Cons of SBP

  • High Cost Over Time: At 6.5% of retired pay, SBP premiums can add up significantly over 30 years. For instance, a retiree earning $10,000 monthly pays $7800 annually in premiums—totaling over $234,000 in 30 years, excluding inflation.
  • Limited Return on Investment: If the retiree and spouse live to their life expectancy, the likelihood of maximizing SBP payouts diminishes.
  • Irrevocable Decision: Once enrolled, opting out is not permitted unless both spouses consent—and even then, flexibility is limited.
  • No Legacy Option: SBP benefits cease after the spouse’s death, meaning no residual value is passed to children or other heirs.

When SBP Might Not Be the Best Fit

SBP is only ideal for some families; an alternative financial strategy may offer better outcomes for healthier individuals.

Here are a few scenarios where SBP may fall short:

  • Dual-Income Families: If both spouses have independent income sources or pensions, the need for SBP decreases. Redirecting premiums toward investments may yield greater financial flexibility.
  • Large Age Gaps or Health Factors: Significant age differences or chronic health issues in the designated beneficiary may reduce the likelihood of receiving meaningful SBP payouts.
  • Preference for Control Over Assets: Families prioritizing asset control and legacy planning may find SBP’s restrictions counterproductive. Private insurance or alternative investments offer flexibility.
This image shows a comparison of life insurance options

Alternatives to SBP: Is Private Life Insurance a Better Option?

Private life insurance policies can be an effective alternative to SBP, offering more flexibility and customization. Here’s why some retirees opt for life insurance instead:

  • Customizable Coverage: Private insurance allows retirees to choose coverage amounts and terms tailored to their family’s needs.
  • Lower Costs for Healthy Retirees: Term life insurance often provides substantial coverage for individuals in good health at lower costs.
  • Legacy Planning: Unlike SBP, life insurance benefits can be directed to multiple heirs or charitable organizations, creating a broader legacy.
  • Potential for Investment Growth: Certain permanent life insurance policies, such as those offered by US VetWealth, combine coverage with tax-advantaged wealth-building opportunities.

Life Insurance Is Not Always a Perfect Substitute

Private insurance requires underwriting, and premiums can be prohibitively expensive for retirees with pre-existing conditions. SBP remains a good option for those unable to afford private coverage.

Making the SBP Decision: Key Questions to Ask

Before committing to SBP, consider the following:

  1. How Long Do You Expect to Live?

    While difficult to predict, life expectancy is crucial in evaluating whether SBP is worth the cost.

  2. What Are Your Beneficiary’s Financial Needs?

    Assess whether SBP payouts sufficiently cover your spouse’s living expenses or if alternative strategies are needed.

  3. Can You Maximize Your Investment Elsewhere?

    Explore whether redirecting SBP premiums toward investments, private insurance, or other financial vehicles could yield greater returns.

  4. Do You Need Guaranteed Coverage?

    If health concerns make private insurance inaccessible, SBP offers a safety net without underwriting requirements.

Why US VetWealth Recommends an Alternative Approach

At US VetWealth, we understand the complexities of retirement planning for military families. Our experience has shown that many retirees can achieve better outcomes by replacing SBP with tailored life insurance strategies.

Here’s how our approach works:

  • Comprehensive Analysis: We start with a free SBP replacement analysis, helping you understand the total value of your military pension and explore alternative strategies.

Defensive and Offensive Planning

  • Defense: Calculate the cost of replicating SBP’s guaranteed income through private insurance.
  • Offense: Design an investment plan that uses redirected SBP premiums to build long-term wealth.
war chest strategy

Flexible Solutions

Our plans include low-cost term life insurance policies with options to convert to permanent policies, ensuring adaptability as your needs evolve.

How to Decide If SBP Is Right for You

Enrolling in SBP depends on your unique circumstances, health, financial goals, and family dynamics. To make an informed choice:

  1. Conduct an SBP Analysis: Use resources like the Department of Defense’s actuarial calculators or consult with a professional to estimate the costs and benefits of SBP for your situation.
  2. Explore Alternatives: Investigate private insurance and investment options to determine whether they offer more value for the costs.
  3. Seek Expert Guidance: Schedule a consultation with a financial advisor experienced in military retirement planning, such as the specialists at US VetWealth.

Is the Survivor Benefit Plan Worth It?

The Survivor Benefit Plan (SBP) offers a dependable safety net for military families. However, its one-size-fits-all approach only suits some. While SBP guarantees an income for your spouse in the event of your death, its high cost, lack of flexibility, and limited legacy potential may make private insurance or alternative investments more attractive.

At US VetWealth, we can help you confidently navigate the SBP decision. Whether you choose SBP or an alternative strategy, we aim to ensure your family’s financial security aligns with your long-term goals.

Contact us for a free SBP analysis, or visit our website to learn more about tailored retirement solutions for military families.

Scott Tucker About Photo (1) 2

Scott R. Tucker

Scott R. Tucker is an author, speaker, and founder of US VetWealth, a military retirement financial consulting brand dedicated to helping military retirees take control of their financial future. A West Point graduate and former Army officer with over 16 years of experience, Scott has guided thousands of veterans in creating personalized financial strategies prioritizing autonomy, protection, and profitability. Through his books, presentations, and innovative online platform, Scott empowers retirees to maximize their benefits and build a secure, purpose-driven future.

Disclaimer: The views expressed by Scott R. Tucker are for educational purposes only and do not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. Scott is a licensed insurance professional offering financial services and products. Always consult with a qualified advisor before making financial decisions.

Topic Categories

BOOK A CALL

Read More